Chapter Review

KEY TERMS

Terms in bold are defined in the glossary.

Problems

DATA ANALYSIS PROBLEM
  • 26. Mirror-Image Enzymes As noted in Chapter 3, “The amino acid residues in protein molecules are almost all l stereoisomers.” It is not clear whether this selectivity is necessary for proper protein function or is an accident of evolution. To explore this question, Milton and colleagues (1992) studied an enzyme made entirely of d stereoisomers. The enzyme they chose was HIV protease, the proteolytic enzyme made by HIV that converts inactive viral pre-proteins to their active forms as described earlier in Figure 6-28.

    Previously, Wlodawer and coworkers (1989) had reported the complete chemical synthesis of HIV protease from l-amino acids (the l-enzyme), using the process shown in Figure 3-30. Normal HIV protease contains two Cys residues at positions 67 and 95. Because chemical synthesis of proteins containing Cys is technically difficult, Wlodawer and colleagues substituted the synthetic amino acid l-α-amino-n-butyric acid (Aba) for the two Cys residues in the protein. They did this to “reduce synthetic difficulties associated with Cys deprotection and ease product handling.”

    1. The structure of Aba is shown below.
      A structure represents a molecule. The molecule has a central C H bonded to C O O minus on the right, N H 3 plus on the left, and C H 2 further bonded to C H 3 above.

      Why was this a suitable substitution for a Cys residue?

      In their study, Milton and coworkers synthesized HIV protease from d-amino acids, using the same protocol as the earlier study (Wlodawer et al.). Formally, there are three possible outcomes for the folding of the d-protease: (1) the same shape as the l-protease; (2) the mirror image of the l-protease, or (3) something else, possibly inactive.

    2. For each possibility, decide whether or not it is a likely outcome and defend your position.

      In fact, the d-protease was active: it cleaved a particular synthetic substrate and was inhibited by specific inhibitors. To examine the structure of the d- and l-enzymes, Milton and coworkers tested both forms for activity with d and l forms of a chiral peptide substrate and for inhibition by d and l forms of a chiral peptide-analog inhibitor. Both forms were also tested for inhibition by the achiral inhibitor Evans blue. The findings are given in the table.

      Inhibition
      Substrate hydrolysis Peptide inhibitor
      HIV protease d form l form d form l form
      l form + +
      d form + +
    3. Which of the three models proposed above is supported by these data? Explain your reasoning.
    4. Would you expect chymotrypsin to digest the d-protease? Explain your reasoning.
    5. Would you expect total synthesis from d-amino acids followed by renaturation to yield active enzyme for any enzyme? Explain your reasoning.

References